Property Description
Set on 1.19± acres overlooking Fresh Pond, this traditional offers privacy, an elevated position overlooking the water, and southwest-facing light with sunset views. Largely hidden from the road, the property enjoys a quiet setting above one of Shelter Island's treasured glacial freshwater ponds. A gravel circular drive approaches the cedar-shingled façade, framed by established landscaping and gabled rooflines. The interior has been updated in 2026, including refinished floors, renovated bathrooms, refreshed exteriors and freshly painted interiors. A gracious entry is framed by a covered porch and a central Palladian-style window above the front door, bringing natural light into the foyer and halls. The double-height living room is imbued with natural light from a wall of windows and glass doors, creating an open yet grounded gathering space centered on a fireplace with custom built-ins. Above, a connecting balcony spans the room, linking the upper level while maintaining a sense of separation between the bedroom wings. The kitchen includes a center prep island and a breakfast bar, with an adjacent dining area facing the pond. A laundry room and powder room are set just off the kitchen, with convenient access to the attached two-car garage. The first-floor primary bedroom includes a renovated bath and walk-in closet. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms reflect the home's architecture, with varied ceiling lines that add dimension. The lower level has a finished office with separate entrance and an unfinished area with waterside windows that are ready for finishing. Outdoor amenities include a hot tub overlooking the water and a screened gazebo positioned for relaxed afternoons or casual gatherings. A path leads down to the pond and dock, offering access to the shoreline and the surrounding landscape
Property Details 28 Lake Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964
General
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Interior Features
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Exterior Features
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Additional Features
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Schools
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Agent Compensation
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Financial Considerations
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Financial Considerations
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Size & Lot
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Utilities
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Activity
- {{Item.Label}}: {{Item.Value}}
Estimated Monthly Mortgage Calculator
This calculator is provided by Burrow Services, Inc. for informational purposes. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Values indicated are estimates and may not be accurate and are only to be used as a guide. This calculator should not be relied upon in any way as the sole source of information. Please consult your financial, tax, or legal advisers for an accurate assessment of your mortgage payments and any advice relating to your personal circumstances.